Ask HN: Any experienced devs who use AI extensively in their work?
I know that vibe-coding has an obvious appeal to non-technical people and those who don't have a lot of experience, but I was wondering if those who have extensive technical experience get use out of AI coding tools.
If you do, what workflows have worked best for you? What models do you trust? Do you believe that it may be a problem offloading thought you would do yourself otherwise to a model?
I couldn't quite tell from the wording of your question if you want to hear from developers who avoid the use of AI as well, so sorry if my comment here is unwelcome in the discussion.
I'm a senior web developer and help maintain hundreds of PHP repositories for work. I avoid the use of AI as best I can. When I do ask questions to an LLM, I feel that I'm partaking in a dirty habit that I should quit. I don't have anything for that installed on my machine/integrated in my IDE. I feel that using LLMs to understand and solve problems is unreliable, a barrier for my personal development, a threat to the future of the industry I work in, unfair to those who wrote the content it is trained on, and bad for the environment.
I also largely feel the same way about other AI products, such as image generation.
Use them extensively in code analysis of unfamiliar code bases. Much more cognitively engaging to be able to engage in socratic interrogation than to fail to be able to because I am bogged down in bookkeeping.
Also use them for completion to spec of specific functions/components, as a kind of pairing. Permits staying at high cognitive engagement again without getting bogged down.
A lot of work is local, qwen and mistral models are go tos.
I've been coding for nearly 20 years. Many projects.
Recently tackled a huge project solo; something large enough with high enough performance that i wouldnt attempt it without a team to build it.
I have a working prototype in production thanks to ai, it's nearly entirely coded with AI. It's big enough of a project that im watching gemini pro take 5 minutes, and fail at replace strings. Which pisses me off because it's burning my limit on its own fails. It's also pretty vague with limits; im always surprised when i finally hit the limit.
Now, what ive achieved would have been utterly impossible for a non-dev to 'vibe code' no matter the quality of AI model.
>If you do, what workflows have worked best for you? What models do you trust? Do you believe that it may be a problem offloading thought you would do yourself otherwise to a model?
I use many different models. I trust them all frankly. GPT 20B is ultra fast and can be trusted. Different models for different purposes. Obviously big refactors, it's preferred to go with a big cloud pro model.
[dead]